Weakley County mineral severance tax proposal fails in special-called meeting

WEAKLEY COUNTY, Tenn. — A proposed mineral severance tax increase failed during a special called meeting of the Weakley County Commission, with commissioners voting 10-6 against the measure.

The proposal sought to raise the county’s mineral severance tax from the current rate, starting at 20 cents per metric ton and gradually increasing to 35 cents per metric ton by 2035. County officials estimated the tax could generate approximately $44,000 per year, with supporters saying the revenue would go toward road improvements and other county needs.

This was not the first time the resolution came before the commission. A similar measure passed unanimously in March 2025 but was never enacted into state law.

Mayor Dale Hutcherson said state legislators had previously opened the door for counties like Weakley to act on the issue.

“Last year, our state legislature implemented a bill that allowed for counties that had mineral severance from the ground to elevate their mineral severance tax from 15 cents per metric ton to 20 cents per metric ton,” Hutcherson said.

Opposition from commissioners

Several commissioners raised concerns about where the tax revenue would actually go and what impact it would have on local businesses.

Commissioner Marcus Hopper questioned whether the money would benefit the roads used by clay company trucks.

“The problem I have is you’re asking them to pay this tax, and we can’t even guarantee this money will even be used on the roads they drive on anyway. It could be used in Martin where the trucks don’t even drive,” Hopper said.

Commissioner David Hawks warned the tax could put local jobs and investment at risk.

“Nobody in this county that drives roads is going to see anything change if we put this on these people. And I think we’re taking a risk of losing companies that are paying considerable dollars to this county,” Hawks said.

Critics also noted that even with the additional revenue, the county could only afford to resurface about three miles of road. They pointed out that clay companies already contribute to the local economy through property taxes, investments, and jobs.

Chairman defends proposal

Chairman Dennis Doster acknowledged the clay companies’ contributions but argued the county’s low tax rate and strong fiscal management made the additional levy reasonable.

“We are the second-lowest property tax rate in the state of Tennessee. They are benefitting in a county that has been extremely well managed,” Doster said.

Doster also said the extra revenue could be directed toward emergency services and education.

Hopper pushed back in an appeal to fellow commissioners before the vote.

“If you vote yes today on this, it’s going to look like that you care more about a penny or 5 cents at this moment than you care about the citizens of Weakley County,” Hopper said.

The measure failed 10-6. The next county commission meeting is scheduled for March 16.

For more local news, click here.